My Paladin had to choose between saving a town or his sacred armor

Last session, my level 5 Paladin had to pick between saving a burning orphanage and keeping his +1 plate armor that was about to get crushed by a collapsing support beam. I chose to dive in and save the kids, lost the armor entirely, but the DM let me roll a performance check to rally the townsfolk into rebuilding. Ended up rolling a natural 20 and got a new set of gear forged by the grateful blacksmith two weeks later. Has anyone else had a moment where losing something valuable made the story way better?

2 comments

2 Comments

jason_stone1229d ago

Nah man, it's plate armor not the end of the world.

julia_burns929d ago

Used to think keeping your gear was always the right call but stories like this prove me wrong. That performance check turning into a whole town rebuild sounds way more memorable than just keeping some fancy armor.