📢
6
c/bicycle-mechanics•mason.juliamason.julia•27d ago

I've been over-tightening bottom bracket cups for years without knowing it.

A customer brought in a vintage Trek with a creaking threaded bottom bracket. I put my usual force on the fixed cup, but the creak came back after a week. He brought it back and said, 'My old shop teacher always said to stop when the wrench feels solid, not when your arm hurts.' I tried his way, just snugging it up firm, and the noise is gone for good now. How do you all judge the right torque on parts without a gauge?
3 comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log In
3 Comments
zara512
zara51227d ago
Honestly, @theas94 has a point about the beam wrench, but how do you know when the shell is faced well enough to even trust a torque reading?
3
jade_hernandez
Seriously, people overthink this stuff.
10
theas94
theas9427d ago
That shop teacher advice is way too vague for something critical. "Feels solid" means totally different things to different people. For a threaded bottom bracket, you really need to chase and face the shell first, then proper torque is key. A cheap beam-type torque wrench for the big stuff takes the guesswork out. Why risk crushing a frame or having it come loose?
0